Calling Time on Call The Midwife

Call the Midwife’, the innocuous Sunday night BBC drama about a group of midwives in Poplar is entering it’s sixth series this month. The cheery nuns, the starched white midwife caps and community spirit in the face of adversity place ‘Call the Midwife’ squarely in the halcyon, simpler days-of-yore that most of our BBC dramas […]

Brooklyn Shakeshaft Ward
27th February 2017

Call the Midwife’, the innocuous Sunday night BBC drama about a group of midwives in Poplar is entering it’s sixth series this month. The cheery nuns, the starched white midwife caps and community spirit in the face of adversity place ‘Call the Midwife’ squarely in the halcyon, simpler days-of-yore that most of our BBC dramas inhabit. Until Brexit and the tide of racism it brought with it, this all seemed harmless fun and although I’m not exactly the target demographic I used to be a fan. However, I can’t ignore the massive problem the BBC has around race any longer. ‘Call the Midwife’ scored incredibly low with viewers of colour, and with good reason. There are very few episodes that include people of colour, and in those that do, the character’s race is usually their main storyline.

“By reducing people of colour to stereotypes in our dramas, we alienate a growing part of our population”

Yes, the show is set in the late 1950s and there would have been very few ethnic minorities in London, but these characters deserve proper storylines, with proper character development, as much as their white counterparts. By reducing people of colour to stereotypes in our dramas, we alienate a growing part of our population. At a time when television should be becoming more accessible we are reinforcing divides that run much deeper than Sunday night viewing habits.

Despite this I had high hopes for the Christmas episode. The show had had a few month’s breaks, and I hoped the growing acknowledgment of racism in television would have trickled down to the writers. What followed was one of the biggest indulgences in the ‘white saviour’ narrative I’ve ever seen on the television. When a mission hospital in South Africa is threatened with closure, the ever helpful Nonnatus midwives hop on the plane to assist it’s ailing doctor (firstly, who’s running the midwifery in Poplar while they’re away?? I spy a plot hole..). While this could be seen as a noble pursuit, the wealthy, upper-middle-class nurses proceed to patronise their patients and generally disregard their culture.

The community is constantly referred to as ‘those people,’ and their poverty often met with disdain and shock by the midwives. Nothing sums up the sly racism of this episode more than the sight of the cast enjoying an idyllic picnic on a ‘Whites Only’ beach, eating food more decadent than anything anyone in the rural South African village would be able to afford. While this may be a very accurate representation of missionary work in South Africa, the fact that these characters, as opposed to the black villagers, are viewed as the heroes is incredibly damaging.

By showing them to be enjoying something that caused untold damage to a nation, and repackage it as light entertainment, is nothing short of shameful. There are ways to show race sensitively, but this is not one. Dear BBC, this show might be set in the 1950s, but it appears you’ve got stuck there.

(Visited 248 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments

  1. As a white person myself, this reads like it was written by a white person .."there would have been very few ethnic minorities in London. .. By reducing people of colour to stereotypes in our dramas .."

    What I understand my Black anti-racism teachers are saying, is that ALL white people are racist. That's because it's a system, of white false/pseudo-supremacy - not personal bigotry.

    Can we please have an anti-racist analysis of Call the Midwife written by Black people, and people of colour, from Poplar?

    1. I’m a person of color and I would love to see how this critique is inaccurate. What do you think a POC would say that is different? That it’s okay for shows to illustrate the cultural differences as one being being vastly superior and one being clueless and insufficient, even though the latter is only reaching these difficulties as a direct result of the imposition of the former. Childbirth in African tribal cultures are well documented as being without complications until western society decided they knew better. The show is accurate historically but the validation of the white culture as the protagonist, encouraging the Africans to get with the times is structurally racist.

ReLated Articles
magnifiercross
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap