Horror has always drawn on the darker side of human nature, exploring what people are capable of when desire turns into something more sinister. Violence and jealousy are hardly unfamiliar territory for the genre, but the role of male entitlement within these stories is worth looking at more closely. Why are so many male characters unable to accept rejection and what does it say about the way we understand desire when a woman’s attention is treated as something a man is owed?
In many horror films, rejection is treated less as an ordinary part of life and more as a personal injury inflicted upon a man. His feelings become the central tragedy, while the woman’s discomfort takes the backseat. We’re invited to understand his pain and sometimes even sympathise with him, while she’s left to deal with the consequences.
...Cinema has a long history of romanticising persistence, presenting men who refuse to give up as devoted rather than threatening... Horror takes that familiar romantic fantasy and asks what happens when he refuses to take no for an answer...
This becomes particularly unsettling when you consider how easily obsession can be mistaken for love. Cinema has a long history of romanticising persistence, presenting men who refuse to give up as devoted rather than threatening. We’re used to the idea that if someone keeps trying, eventually they’ll get the girl. Horror takes that familiar romantic fantasy and asks what happens when he refuses to take no for an answer. Suddenly, the grand gestures aren’t so grand, and this persistence stops looking so charming.
A recent example is Obsession, which takes this idea to a disturbing extreme. Bear doesn’t just want Nikki to love him; he wants to control her. His feelings become less about loving her for who she is and more about having her for himself. Rather than risk rejection, he attempts to eliminate that possibility all together, treating Nikki's autonomy as an obstacle to overcome.
Bear is an extreme example, but male entitlement in horror isn't always supernatural or quite so obvious. In The Invisible Man, control is disguised as love, with the protagonist Cecilia's attempts to escape an abusive relationship met by a man who refuses to accept that he no longer has any claim over her. Meanwhile, Fresh takes male entitlement to a more grotesque extreme, reducing women to commodities for male consumption.
Although the films both approach the subject differently, both expose the same underlying assumption: women's live, bodies and choices are ultimately there for men to control. The horror lies in how differently that entitlement can present itself, from the seemingly devoted boyfriend to the man who sees women as little more than objects.
Perhaps the real horror of male entitlement is how easily it disguises itself as love. When obsession becomes devotion and rejection becomes an injustice, the line between romance and control begins to blur. The most frightening thing about these men is that they rarely believe they are the villains of their own stories.