Are we reading for pleasure or clout?

How do we know when Goodreads has gone too far?

Amber Watson
19th November 2026
Image credit: Hannah Green
Why do you read a book? Do you read it for pleasure, or can you just not wait to log it on Goodreads and hit your reading target? Goodreads has recently added half and quarter stars to reviews, thrilling its 150 million worldwide members. Does this mean that people care more about posting their reviews online rather than actually reading the book; has reading lost its meaning?

Goodreads allows you to follow your friends, see what they are reading, join group discussions all whilst recommending books for you and showing you other people’s opinions. It can feel as though Goodreads has predominately been made for promoting other books.

In my experience, finishing a book can feel like an accomplishment, and often you want to remember all the books you have read. Keeping a notebook full of my reviews was how I kept track, but finding Goodreads made this process so much easier. For me, Goodreads isn’t about the social, or competitive aspect, it is just a fun way of digitalising my reviews.

Book discussions can date back to before the 18th century...

For older generations, who maybe aren’t quite so chronically online, reading can be more authentic; picking up a book and simply reading it for pleasure, discussing it with friends and family. Book discussions can date back to before the 18th century – reading literature and talking about in coffee houses. Is the concept of Goodreads not the same?

...reading is a wholesome act, not performative or artificial.

Except Goodreads is expanding from small discussions to a worldwide book club, connecting many more people together. Therefore, it could be argued that reading creates community, not clout. People enjoy reading and feeling a part of something. This suggests reading is a wholesome act, not performative or artificial.

Reading a good book and recommending it to a friend parallels Goodreads recommending you books. But in doing this, is Goodreads not limiting physical human interaction? Is reading becoming just one more thing that ends up being all over the internet? This causes us to pause and consider where we actually get our inspiration to read from: is Goodreads telling us to reach our reading goal, or is BookTok promoting books for us to buy?

With the omnipresence of BookTok and other forms of social media, have younger generations stopped giving books that are not popular on these platforms a chance? Take yourself, for example, consider when the last time you went into a bookshop without the intention of buying a book you had already seen online was.

There is no rule guide to reading, if you are reading for clout or reading for pleasure, as long as we keep reading then surely it can’t lose its meaning.

Some people might see reading as a trendy social media competition, but even if you are reading for (what some might consider) the wrong reasons, you are still reading and that is important. There is no rule guide to reading, if you are reading for clout or reading for pleasure, as long as we keep reading then surely it can’t lose its meaning.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ReLated Articles
[related_post]
magnifiercross
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap