Commonwealth Summit: Will the UK Finally Face Up to The Scars of Slavery and Climate Change?

Sanya Tayal debates what reparations could mean for the Commonwealth, and whether it would really be enough to atone for Britain's colonialist past and climate-destroying present.

Sanya Tayal
11th November 2024
Source: Wikimedia Commons, Simon Dawson
In recent years, there has been increasing worldwide pressure on Britain to confront its combined heritage of colonial exploitation and climate change through reparations. At October’s Commonwealth Summit, Commonwealth countries have increasingly emphasised how Britain's early industrialisation and colonial policies resulted in a double burden: historical poverty from slavery and colonialism, followed by disproportionate vulnerability to climate change impacts. Britain has refused to pay the reparations and fully acknowledge its colonial past. Is reparations really a way for Britain to finally face up to its complex past? 

Britain’s Imperial past was tinged with bloodshed, violence, brutality, and slavery. Millions of indigenous people were traded as slaves. The British oppression left wounds, which are still bleeding today as the Commonwealth countries continue to bear the brunt of colonial oppression. This comes in the form of historical trauma as well as health crises. 

Indigenous peoples endure disproportionate mental and physical ailments when compared to settler populations. Type 2 diabetes is the consequence of colonial exploitation in South Asia. This is because British colonial rule's exploitative economic methods led to a disproportionately high number of famines. Indigenous businesses failed as a result of these economic policies, destroying their cultures and languages. In India, the flooding of cheap fabrics and textiles from Britain impeded and harmed its indigenous textile industry. The historical pain induced by colonial control is manifested in the form of slave trade and indentured labour. The exploitation and bloodshed that occurred throughout colonisation also exacerbated the trauma. 

The harsh irony is that colonial exploitation drove the Industrial Revolution, which in turn is playing a major role in the current environmental catastrophe.

This past debt is further complicated by climate change. Rising sea levels, harsh weather, and altered agricultural patterns pose dangers to many Commonwealth members, particularly small island governments and developing ones. These nations are disproportionately affected by climate change, despite having made very small contributions to global carbon emissions. The harsh irony is that colonial exploitation drove the Industrial Revolution, which in turn is playing a major role in the current environmental catastrophe.

Therefore, are reparations really enough? The answer is no. Reparations can be seen as a way of returning the trillions of dollars that the British rule drained from its colonies. However, it can never compensate for the emotional and historical trauma caused by colonial rule. Some countries like the Bahamas are dealing with damaging effects of climate change due to rising sea levels and reparations could help them come back on their feet. However, before paying the reparation, Britain needs to face up to its disastrous past and accept it. An apology and owning up to the exploitation caused during colonial rule could be the first step. While an apology does not guarantee forgiveness from formerly colonised nations, it is an important step for Britain in confronting the stark realities of its imperial past, starting up a long-overdue process of historical reconciliation and accountability.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ReLated Articles
magnifiercross
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap