The idea of budgets being used as a political tool are far from new. The forms of performative cruelty seen under the old Tory regime are all too common for the average citizen, especially if you have ever had to deal with a form of benefits or student loan. Need I remind us of the disaster that was the Truss budget that dropped the pound to decade lows to the Dollar and the Euro.
The Truss budget aimed to reduce public fiscal pressure by cutting a staggering £45 billion of tax which reduced economic confidence in the UK. The guardian described the budget as a “Dash” for growth, citing Trussonomics as “Alarming”. The Treasury Permanent Secretary accredits many of the UK’s high borrowing rates today to these exact budgetarianist policies.
It is important then, considering the estimated £30 Billion black hole that the Truss debarcle left, to examine the dent in which austerity and budgetarianism has created for the United Kingdom’s economic prosperity.
Budgetarianism, the term defined by economics Professor Chadha at Cambridge University, details the performative nature of the annual budget year on year in the UK. Writing under the Johnson government when Sunak was Chancellor, he focuses on arbitrary targets and the impracticality of arbitrary restrictions whilst ignoring critical infrastructure deficits.
A hallmark of Tory governments starting with Cameron, the performative austerity could be seen from the beginning of the 2011 budget which decimated welfare in the UK. In the aftermath of the devastation that was the 2008 crash, the Brown government had shored up banks at a huge bill to save the UK from the worst of the crisis like America. Yet according to economist Paul Krugman for the New York Times, Brown “defined the character of the worldwide rescue effort”. The 2010’s austerity was almost synonymous with the response to the expenses of the crash, often being described as short term performativism; the type that defined the decade’s administrative course.
British Spending is expected to reach upwards of £1.3tn across 2025-2026 according to the OBR. Concurrently, the national debt has reached over £3tn, rising 18% from 2010 to 2019 and costing some £120bn a year. This type of debt rise is only seen elsewhere during major financial incidents, indicating that austerity and budgetarianist politics have been a key inflammatory factor. The debt spikes also run concurrently with the Tory Governments of the 21st Century. So, knowing this, what has Andy Burnham’s October budget done to present practical, non-political information or does it resemble the politicisation of its predecessors?
Burnham’s Tax increases are meagre on certain industries like the banks, with his new windfall only generating £1bn per year. Real terms income raises for working Britons was only increased by 0.6% that barely even puts a dent in inflation despite the treasury claiming it was “redistributive”. There has also been a slightly Trumpian declaration of £100 for every British household.
Yet Burnham and the cabinet are recognisant of the fact that the budget does not stretch very far. Even Starmerite Darren Jones declared it a “Steady-as-she-goes” budget; in essence all wings of Labour know there is a lot to be done. It can be summed up in one word: accountability. Whereas Trussonomics and Austerity were almost self-insistent, Burnhamist budgetary policy can admit fault.
And that is the critical point of this discussion, caution and the admittance of falibility is divisive. Burnham could easily cut taxes just like governments before him, yet that would simply continue the economic death spiral this country has been on for 18 years. A planned and extensive direction is necessary to strengthen the core of the British economy, but that requires full financial focus instead of reactionary short-term relief. This is antithetical to the politics of the budget – and it shows.
In Burnham’s first 5 months as prime minister, checking twitter could have you believe he was a radical dictator. The Times predicted a “Red October” budget of high spending; the Daily Express stated it was “A Budget for Burnham, not Britain”. Both of these accounts fail to mention the 10 year plan set to be revealed in December, and many more further ignore the progress.
It is not possible to predict the efficacy of the 10 year plan, but it’s inconceivably more than anything any government has presented since Brown (that wasn’t trying to actively sabotage our economy for fishing rights). It demonstrates Burnham is willing to be unpopular to achieve his goals, and I would argue at least for now, is an attempt to split from budgetarian politics.
(Image by Lauren Hurley, Number 10 Downing Street. Crown Copyright, Open Government License)
