The art of judging a book by its cover

As an English Literature undergraduate student, I myself have received and bought my fair share of limited and collector’s editions of my favourite novels. However, it is no surprise that they come at an extra price for the beautifully sprayed edges, the clothbound covers, and the elaborate foil-stamped designs. So, is the extra cost really worth it? 

The answer to this question is heavily dependent on the perspective of the reader and the purpose of their purchase. More often than not, they are considered as treasured keepsakes for collectors, literature lovers and fans. However, there are valid arguments against these editions, with people concerned about the unsustainability and financial risk that has been elevated by consumerism in literature. 

Some people, particularly bibliophiles, would argue that collecting books is perhaps just as much a hobby as reading is. Penguin’s Clothbound Classics affirm this ideology. Designed by Coralie Bickford-Smith, this series is marketed for display, making them an object of aesthetics and sentimentality rather than practicality. Featuring intricate symbolic patterns, integrated ribbon markers and colourful endpapers, you cannot resist admiring this collection. Therefore, there is not a single doubt that these books make a perfect gift for those who love literature or for someone who holds a particular novel close to their heart. With over 110 volumes, it is an ongoing collection of hardbacks with new titles added regularly to the series, showcasing the popularity of these editions. For many, the joy of purchasing a beautiful book is fuelled by sentimental value and the pleasure of owing a piece of art that incorporates your interests. 

Yet, at a price averagely sitting between £15 to £18 they are considerably more expensive than your average novel, which makes them slightly more inaccessible. Moreover, the argument of consumerism persists as the sustainability of owning multiple versions of the exact same novel is questioned. Realistically, do I need a fifth copy of Wuthering Heights just because it has Jacob Elordi’s face on? Ultimately, for literature lovers like me, collecting and receiving these books is a pleasure as I add them to my carefully curated collection, accentuating the beauty of my bookshelves. Nevertheless, I completely understand if you believe this is absurd and question my financial choices when I’m debating on purchasing the clothbound version of 1984 because the details are so enticing.