Three weeks ago, a Casemiro-inspired United overcame arch-rivals, Manchester City, in a thrilling victory that saw the Red Devils enter the title race for the first time this season. The Brazilian then even further endeared himself to the Old Trafford faithful has he netted twice to break down a stubborn Reading side in the FA Cup. However, the former Champions League winner went from hero to zero in a matter of moments as his reckless yellow card in United’s first game against Crystal Palace saw the midfielder suspended for the top of the table clash against Arsenal. Subsequently, Arsenal ran out 3-2 winners, creating daylight once again between them and United.
Just two games back from suspension, another moment of madness saw Casemiro, playing in a midfield that was cruising through the game at 2-0, grab opponent Will Hughes by the neck, forcefully moving him back. A straight red card followed, placing him out of action for the next three matches, and leaving his side with ten men and twenty minutes left to play. United did concede late on but held out for a 2-1 victory, cementing themselves in the top 4. However, the game was followed by a huge debate surrounding the decision. Was Casemiro’s grab forceful enough to warrant a red card? Was the fact that the Brazilian placed two hands on Hughes’ neck rather than one significant? Opinions and answers to these questions floated around footballing media for days as United came to terms with the fact that they were missing their talismanic midfielder for three crucial games.
Casemiro’s grab at Hughes certainly had intent. It is difficult to conclude whether he held the Palace man for a significant amount of time, with pictures of the event certainly not favouring the United man’s case. It is the consequence of United having to cope without their main man that is harder to take, with Christian Eriksen’s poorly timed injury only adding to their squad availability crisis. A deadline day signing of Austrian midfielder, Marcel Sabitzer, ensued and whilst this certainly was a good signing, without the poor discipline of Casemiro, Erik Ten-Haag may have been able to spend his money in more necessary places.
