These influential figures are used as marketing tools for fashion, cosmetic surgery, and dieting trends, advertising the perfect look for the perfect life. Yet, this is the reason why people assume it is justified to find flaws and loopholes within these trendsetters, as a society that fixates on self-image and identity.
This leaves artists conflicted as their artistry is nothing without their aesthetics. Pop icons such as Billie Eilish and Lizzo have addressed the public scrutiny and rejected any notions of weight shaming, as fans should be more concerned over talent than tummy size. This stance is undeniably true and essential for protecting their mental health.
wanting to comment on a celebrity's weight is understandable. That doesn’t make it okay.
Yet, isn’t the irony striking when similar artists appear on Fashion Week or an award show wearing near to nothing, such as Beyonce, Rihanna, Paris Hilton, and even model Bianca Censori, Kanye West's wife making her appearance at the 67th Grammy in a sheer gown, controversially leaving very little to the imagination. Do appearances like this not directly invite comments to be made about their bodies, if they are wearing minimal clothing? British Vogue posted an article in 2023 stating that “wanting to comment on a celebrity's weight is understandable. That doesn’t make it okay.”
There is an undeniable contradiction and hypocrisy within this culture. On one hand, celebrities like Billie Eilish and Lizzo demand respect, attempting to hone the public focus from their body to their talent. However, they are caught in the very issue they condemn. There is pressure on celebrities who must partake in these beauty standards while also rejecting them. On the other hand, some public figures embrace their body, drawing media attention to their looks. This blurs the line between having self-expression and being objectified.
It is undeniable that this argument is complex, revealing troubling paradoxes of what it should be and what it is
Moreover, the influencers promoting these contradictions of body-positivity and unattainable beauty ideals leave many users on social media perpetuating the same habits or finding unhealthy comparisons between themselves and their favourite icons. According to the BBC, a survey conducted on 227 female university students in 2019 found that they weigh their appearances against peers and celebrities. Sadly this reveals the effect social media and celebrities have on the younger population. This calls into question whether these people or organizations, such as fashion and beauty coverages online should be held accountable for what they are truly advertising.
It is undeniable that this argument is complex, revealing troubling paradoxes of what it should be and what it is, and it can only be ceased if the industry and media stop fixating on appearances and start prioritizing talent. But we all know this will never be a reality. Is it wrong to comment a celebrity’s or anyone else’s body? Yes, absolutely. But will it stop? No.