The album is centred around melancholia and depression despite some light-hearted and amusing lyrics like “pissing in the corner of a hotel suite” from 'Little Girl'. Yet, some have said that the album was disappointing – that the hard-hitting lyrics and themes sometimes get lost in translation with the delicate and elegant compositions.
Branching out from the vibrant and rhythmic album Jubilee, which is still my favourite album so far, For Melancholy Brunettes (& sad women) provides a different yet still refreshing avenue for the band, especially considering Zauner’s open experience as a queer person. After a few listens, here are some of my favourite songs from the album.
'Winter in LA' – This is my favourite song on the album at the moment, though I expect that to change as I continue re-listening and discovering new details. The song expresses a romantic guilt and internal struggle as they wish they were a “happier woman” that they believe their partner deserves. Love feeling weighed down by personal emotions and insecurities is something that resonates and connects with many and listening to this song emanates the essence of a melancholic brunette. Zauner’s vocals are particularly shown off in this song and alongside the violin, are soothing but at the same time heartbreaking.
In 'Honey Water', there is a gut-aching guitar instrumental that feels perfect for that driving through a tunnel energy. Jeff Bridges features in 'Picture Window' where their voices blend smoothly together in a way you wouldn’t expect to add elements of country music. 'Here is Someone' creates ethereal harmonies and melodies, accompanied by a soft dreamy guitar similar to Ben Howard’s music. Finally, Zauner informed her aesthetics and arrangements based on melancholic movies, one being Orlando and the lead single Orlando in Love evokes intense emotions with classical influences.
This album as a whole flows well and creates a romantical yet wistful experience. While some of the songs have been seen as disappointing, I believe that the differences between albums adds to the variety and uniqueness of Zauner’s ability and voice.